You might have noticed aluminum roofing and asphalt shingle roofs around your neighborhood. You may be wondering what is the difference between aluminum and asphalt, so we’re here to help!
Let’s start with aluminum roofing. Aluminum roofing is made of aluminum roof panels or steel sheets that are covered in a protective coating for weather protection. They come with a warranty for up to 50 years, which means they last longer than any other type of metal roofing materials on the market today. Asphalt shingles, on the other hand, are made from tar and gravels that are melted together before they harden into blocks. These blocks can break off easily over time when exposed to extreme heat or cold conditions like snowstorms or hail storms.
Asphalt Roofing
Asphalt roof design has remained popular among modern homeowners, who are still stunned by the timeless beauty of this roofing material. Asphalt roofing panels have long been one of the most affordable solutions for homeowners, both in terms of cost and convenience of installation. If you live in a traditional home in New York, you can’t just entrust your roofing repair to an inexperienced roofing contractor with no relevant qualifications. You certainly don’t want your lifetime investment to be squandered due to improper installation and maintenance.
Asphalt shingles can be made to look like tile, wood, cedar shakes, or slate, but they offer more benefits than these other roofing materials. Asphalt roofing outperforms metal, steel roofing, and concrete tiles in terms of overall beauty, durability, and sustainability. In comparison to metal and concrete, asphalt shingles are easier to install and require less maintenance.
Listed below are the several types of asphalt shingles:
3-Tab Shingles – if you’re on a budget, 3-tab shingles are one of the most cost-effective solutions. Traditional shingles are made of either durable fiberglass or organic felt paper as the foundation material, and are sometimes coated with mineral grains to give each piece a distinct color appearance.
Dimensional Asphalt Shingles – architectural or laminated shingles have grown in popularity as a result of their distinct appearance and a vast range of styles. Dimensional shingles are multilayered shingles that have been glued together to make them more robust and resistant to all types of weather. Dimensional shingles can be used on a range of home styles and can add a lot of curb appeal to your home.
Premium Asphalt Shingles – you’ll love the elegance of quality asphalt shingles if you now dwell in luxury home with a hint of Spanish colonial architecture. Premium asphalt shingles are similar to dimensional shingles in appearance, but they are thicker and more durable. In places prone to tornadoes, hurricanes, severe winds, and heavy snowfall, these roofing materials are ideal. Because premium shingles are heavier than conventional shingles, they necessitate installation expertise and roofing contractors with extensive knowledge to assure a quality installation.
If you want your old asphalt roof fixed professionally, you’ll need to choose a reputable roofing company with extensive experience installing and repairing various types of asphalt shingles. Visit ManhattanRoofingnyc.com for more information.
Aluminum Roofing
Aluminum is one of the more recent roofing materials. It’s commonly used in standing seam metal roofs, although it can also be utilized in other types of roofing. Aluminum roofing is gradually becoming one of the most widely used roofing materials. Many installers who construct standing seam panels will choose aluminum roofing over other materials because it is simple to work with, does not rust, and requires less upkeep. It appeals to homeowners because, unlike other residential roofing materials, it does not heat up in the sun, resulting in decreased energy expenses.
A hammering press is used to create aluminum roofing in a three-step process. The hammering press machine is first fed with a metal coil. The shingle’s pattern, including the lock flanges, is then stamped out. The shingles are then packaged for distribution after the locks are finalized in the manufacturing process. Most metal shingles also feature seven layers of premium baked-on paint and primer. The bulk of aluminum roofing systems are placed from the bottom to the top, where they are first joined to the drip-edge or starting trim, during installation. Nails, built-in hems, or specific clips hold the aluminum roofing to the top.
What’s the Difference Between Asphalt Shingles and Metal Roofing?
The metal shingle is the ideal modern roofing alternative for anyone looking to bring their home’s appearance and functionality into the twenty-first century. Not only are they durable enough to resist natural disasters like aluminum or steel roofing panels, but they can also be customized to complement your home from the ground up. Metal roofs have consistently been one of the most reliable ways for homeowners to protect themselves from Mother Nature’s worst hurricanes, floods, hail storms, and other natural disasters.
In comparing roofing advantages and disadvantages in between Metal Shingles vs. Asphalt Shingles, it’s helpful to view some key distinctions side by side so you can evaluate which one will work best for your needs or scenario. Metal and asphalt roofing materials appear to be opposed, but closer examination reveals many commonalities. In this article, we’ll look at their fundamental difference in durability, as well as what makes them unique, such as installation requirements and cost considerations.
Metal roofing has a life expectancy of about 80 years and saves 10% to 25% on energy. It is easy to change, but because of the minimal color selections, it is difficult to match colors. Traditional Asphalt Shingles, on the other hand, have a 20-year average lifespan and are inefficient energy saving. It’s easy to replace and comes in a wide variety of colors.
Aluminum Roofs Tend to be More Durable
When it comes to durability and efficiency, aluminum roofing is extremely fireproof, windproof, and impact resistant. It will safeguard structures from external fire hazards and will not deteriorate. All aluminum roofing systems have four-way interlocking with non-exposed fasteners, which adds to the metal roofing system’s durability and protection.
Also, when compared to other roofing materials, aluminum roofing is lighter, putting less stress on the home. Heat and sunshine are resisted by aluminum’s reflective qualities. As a result, aluminum roofing reflects the sun’s rays and helps keep your home cool in the summer. Aluminum shingles reflect the heat from your home back into it throughout the winter. During the summer and winter months, these reflecting characteristics save heating and cooling expenditures.
Shingle Roofs are Cheaper Upfront
A high-quality metal roof will last longer, but the cost will be higher at the time of installation. Metal roofs are often more expensive per 100 square feet, but asphalt shingles are significantly cheaper per 100 square feet. Because it is a more specialist job, its installation will cost you more in metal.
However, you might be able to recover some of the costs of a metal roof in the future because you won’t have to replace it. Homeowners with metal roofs may also qualify for insurance discounts. Installing a metal roof on your main residence may potentially qualify you for tax credits. Moreover, because metal roofs are extremely energy-efficient, you can save money on your monthly heating and cooling bills.
Aluminum Roofs are More Eco-Friendly
Aluminum roofing is recyclable, which means it may be reused once it has served its purpose. Other roofing materials, such as asphalt, add to the huge amount of garbage that ends up in landfills. Furthermore, the reflective characteristics of aluminum roofing shingles reflect the sun’s beams. This can assist in lowering a home’s cooling energy consumption. Aside from the apparent fact of reusing aluminum for use in other applications reduces the need to engineer more, it’s also worth noting that recycling aluminum uses just around a minimal percent of the energy required to make it.
Asphalt Shingle Roofs Generally are Easier to Install and Repair
Asphalt shingles are also popular because they are simple to install and maintain. It’s easier to discover a roofer who can repair and install unique or less often used materials than it is to find a roofer who can repair and install more common materials.
Asphalt roofs will not only be less easy to replace financially in the short term, but they will also cost less to fix in the long run than metal roofs. This explanation is based on the ease with which repairs can be completed. If a few shingles on an asphalt roof need to be changed, it’s simple enough to do it without pulling up the entire roof and starting over. While metal roofing is extremely durable, any serious damage will almost certainly require more than a simple patch or section replacement. Damage to a metal roof usually necessitates a significantly larger repair project.
Is an Aluminum Roof Cheaper Than Shingles?
Aluminum is a more expensive roofing material, especially when compared to asphalt shingles, which are the cheapest option. Aluminum roofing, for example, can cost up to 35% more than steel roofs. Location, roof complexity, and difficulty of installation, as well as material type, all influence the price of roof materials.
In the winter, it may also result in higher energy costs. Another disadvantage of aluminum roofs is that their highly reflective surface reflects most solar heat rather than absorbing it. While this is excellent in the summer, it can force your heating system to work overtime to keep the interior warm in the winter.
Conclusion
To summarize, aluminum roofing is more expensive than other roofing materials, but it is also more environmentally friendly and long-lasting. Aluminum roofing is fire-resistant, wind-resistant, and impact-resistant. It will protect structures from external fire dangers while also ensuring that they do not decay. Asphalt roofing has long been regarded as one of the most cost-effective and easy-to-install roofing options for homeowners. Metal roofs have shown to be one of the most reliable solutions for homeowners to protect themselves against natural disasters in the past. It is always in your best interest to choose what is best for your home. It’s also a good idea to think about things like durability, long-term sustainability, and maintenance costs. TCI Manhattan Roofing skilled roofers are highly competitive and prepared to manage a wide range of roofing issues. Check this link to assist you at ManhattanRoofingnyc.com.
